Perhaps the time has come for us to admit that we are trying to work within a system that encourages us to skew our work toward improving our performance in the rankings rather than focusing on our core educational missions; deploy teams of people to squeeze each ranking data point until it screams, rather than take all possible measures to find students who seek – and will truly benefit from – the distinctive experience we each have to offer. 5. Lessons from Claremont McKenna’s SAT Scandal: Oversight and Accountability February 19, 2012 By Charles C. Johnson and John-Clark Levin 5 Comments Over the last few years, we’ve been pleased to see our alma mater, Claremont McKenna College, shooting upward in the national college rankings. Check out FORBES Top 25 Liberal Arts Colleges for 2017. In 2012, the school admitted that their Dean of Admissions misreported SAT scores for years. But they also defended their school, which has climbed to No. Morse said in a blog that Claremont McKenna’s revised average Critical Reading and Math SAT score for the fall 2010 entering class was 1,385, compared with the originally reported score of 1,410, and the correct percentage of students who graduated in the top 10% of their high school class was 72%, compared with the originally reported figure of 85%. Claremont McKenna Admissions January 31, 2012 A major college admissions scandal is brewing at Claremont McKenna College. Claremont McKenna College lies about students’ admissions statistics. And I’d like to say that I believe that whatever the reason for the transgression, we can all rest assured that it’s an aberration, an unseemly and unfortunate action of a single bad actor – in this case a senior admissions official at what is clearly a fine college. Tulane University in 2012 discovered its business … Harpswell Foundation students. Katherine Cohen, founder and chief executive officer, runs a college admissions strategy business called Ivywise in New York. © 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. News Claremont McKenna College SAT scandal opens debate on college rankings By Adam Fix '13. They've got some real legal obligations here. She says students and parents need to go way beyond rankings. We're just one consumer of these numbers. To preserve the integrity of our rankings, we pulled Claremont McKenna from the list. We could, as Colby and many other colleges have already done, pledge to no longer use rankings to promote ourselves. Sadly, I can’t in good faith say either of those things. Schools, he says, are too focused on rankings. Photo courtesy of New College of the Humanities/Simon Jones. For years, those of us who are entrusted with the job of guiding places like Claremont McKenna or any other institution of higher education have been playing a dangerous game of chicken with college rankings. Share your thoughts », Arizona State University-Downtown Phoenix, Bowling Green State University-Main Campus, Caldwell Community College and Technical Institute, California Polytechnic State University-San Luis Obispo, California State Polytechnic University-Pomona, California State University at Stanislaus, California State University Dominguez Hills, California State University Maritime Academy, California State University-Channel Islands, California State University-San Bernardino, Call to Action: Marketing and Communications in Higher Education, Chabot-Las Positas Community College District, Chicago School of Professional Psychology, Columbia University in the City of New York, Computer Science / Information Technology, CUNY Borough of Manhattan Community College, CUNY Graduate School and University Center, CUNY John Jay College of Criminal Justice, Development / fund raising / alumni affairs, Doane University-Graduate and Professional Studies, East Stroudsburg University of Pennsylvania, Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University-Daytona Beach, Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University-Prescott, Facilities / auxiliary services / sustainability, Fairleigh Dickinson University-Metropolitan Campus, Faith Baptist Bible College and Theological Seminary, Florida Agricultural and Mechanical University, Foothill-DeAnza Community College District, Fuller Theological Seminary in California, Gov. Earlier this year, a senior administrator at Claremont McKenna College in California resigned after acknowledging he falsified college entrance exam scores for years to rankings … In part because we recognize that, much to our dismay, the college experience has been increasingly commodified over the last decade. At the University of California, they did a nationwide survey. To speak loudly and clearly and in a single voice that we will not participate in that kind of system. And suppose we found new ways to collaborate with those who would rank us, ways that generate information to better help prospective students and their families make an informed decision? Claremont McKenna College, a private liberal arts school nestled in the foothills on the eastern outskirts of Los Angeles County, dishonored itself and defrauded the public in a cheap effort to bolster its national rankings in U.S. News and World Report.But if that weren’t bad enough, Claremont’s deception calls into question the very worth of its students, faculty, and graduates. But we also participate – and this admission makes me a bit squeamish – because of the tremendous risk inherent in not doing so. When a misleading op-ed in 'The Wall Street Journal' irks academics, it's time for a fact check on f, 10 strategies to support students and help them learn during the coronavirus crisis (opinion), Wellness and Mental Health in 2020 Online Learning, Former Calvin University professor denied tenure and terminated alleges racial discrimination and re, Long-term online learning in pandemic may impact students' well-being, How to write an effective diversity statement (essay), Live Updates: Latest News on Coronavirus and Higher Education, Black Auburn alumni, students say university needs to change, How to discourage student cheating on online exams (opinion), We are retiring comments and introducing Letters to the Editor. Claremont McKenna College is a private institution that was founded in 1946. In this Thursday, Feb. 2, 2012 photo, students walk through the campus of Claremont McKenna College in Claremont, Calif. By JUSTIN POPE updated 2/5/2012 1:20:32 PM ET … As the president of a small, selective – and, I hesitate to add, highly ranked – liberal arts college, I’d like to say that I’m surprised by the recent news that Claremont McKenna College has been submitting false SAT scores for incoming freshmen to, among others, U.S. News & World Report for the last six years. But why? What the incident should inspire is a collective stand. For five years, a school official falsely inflated the SAT scores of incoming students by 10 to 30 points -- enough to potentially move up on the coveted rankings in publications such as US News & World Report. Jerry Brown rallying support for Proposition 30 on election eve, Grand Valley State University - College of Liberal Arts and Sciences, Grossmont-Cuyamaca Community College District. On a list of the 22 most important factors in determining where to go to college, students ranked the rankings at number 11. Claremont McKenna College is ranked the ninth best liberal arts college in the nation. The Jones Day firm found that Fox employed a "rankings focused" strategy that contributed to the inaccurate reporting, and it's far from the first school to get caught up in the rankings craze. Emory scandal: Critics doubt college ratings. Barmak Nassirian, associate executive director of the American Association of College Registrars, says rankings are a recruitment tool. Claremont McKenna College, a respected institution which played host to a data-rigging scandal. "They want to find courses they want to take, professors they want to study with, what current research is going on, what kinds of extracurricular activities are they going to engage in.". fields, source:iStock.com/clu uses: library digitization, source:iStock.com/CurvaBezier uses:federal funded programs, source:iStock.com/maxuser uses: academy-industry relationships, source:iStock.com/MTMCOINS uses: sergeant, source:iStock.com/SimplyCreativePhotography uses: student finance, source:iStock.com/tillsonburg uses: strikes, source:Wikipedia caption: Notre Dame Quad, source:Wikipedia/Lakshmansrikanth uses: law library, South Dakota School of Mines and Technology, South Metropolitan Higher Education Consortium, South Orange County Community College District, Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville, State University of New York at New Paltz, Stella and Charles Guttman Community College, Student Community College of Baltimore County, Students at Community College of Baltimore County, SUNY College of Agriculture and Technology at Cobleskill, SUNY College of Environmental Science and Forestry, The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Tressel speaks to students on campus. California Admissions scandal reinforces stereotypes but elite colleges admitting more low-income students The nationwide admissions scandal has institutions like Claremont McKenna … Categories: College Admissions, The Rankings. The scandal is raising serious questions about how much we can trust those rankings, which are extremely important for schools and many students. 9 among liberal arts colleges in the U.S. News & World Report. Claremont McKenna College Ranking Factors. We are limited, but we work very hard to get the numbers right.". William D. Adams is the 19th president of Colby College, in Waterville, Maine. Tag Archive: US News College Rankings Scandal. And perhaps the time has come to admit that we are trying to work within a system that is such a powerful corrupting influence on us all that it has the power to make a senior official at a college like Claremont McKenna take the catastrophic professional and reputational risk of fudging SAT data to make already outstanding students look just a shade better. Learn how Claremont McKenna ranks across all of College Factual's rankings including Best Colleges Nationwide, Best Colleges for Your Money, Best Colleges in California and the region, and Best Majors. A top college in California has admitted to sending exaggerated SAT scores to college-ranking services. But, as history has taught us, the tip of the iceberg is sometimes pretty easy to miss. College's fake SAT scores lead to admin's ouster, 60 Minutes: The Perfect Score: Cheating on the SAT, 60 Minutes: College test scammer says he saved lives, California Privacy/Information We Collect. It’s time for us to take collective action. As the president of a small, selective – and, I hesitate to add, highly ranked – liberal arts college, I’d like to say that I’m surprised by the recent news that Claremont McKenna College has been submitting false SAT scores for incoming freshmen to, among others, U.S. News & World Report for the last six years. Through a blend of need-based and merit awards, we provide students and their families financial support for the cost of attendance and participation in special programs, such as our Welcome Orientation Adventures (WOA). Claremont McKenna College is in the top 15% of universities in the world, ranking 679th in the United States and 2390th globally. Learn more including info on tuition, acceptance rates, and more. An entire panoply of sophisticated methods of gaming the system – all on the margins of acceptable practices and mostly, we hope, well clear of the boundary that Claremont McKenna crossed. He said his publication has faced three or four similar incidents in the 25 years that it's reported these rankings. But, as well intentioned as these efforts are, they have done little to mitigate the influence of these instruments. CMC recruits emerging leaders who are committed to meeting the challenges of our complex world, regardless of their financial background, on a need-blind basis. News Rachel Brody February 2, 2012 admissions, admissions officer resigns, california, caroline nyce, claremont, claremont colleges, claremont mckenna, Claremont McKenna College, cmc, cmc admissions office, cmc college president, cmc forum, college, College Admits to Reporting Exaggerated SAT Scores, college rankings, dean richard vos, exaggerating sat scores, featured, forum, … University of Science and Arts of Oklahoma, University of South Florida-Sarasota-Manatee, University of South Florida-St Petersburg, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, West Valley/Mission Community College District, West Virginia School of Osteopathic Medicine, Mental Health Epidemic: Dark Shadow of the COVID Pandemic, Q&A About ‘Learning Innovation and the Future of Higher Education’. While founded as a men's college in 1946, CMC became coeducational in 1976. Brian Kelly, editor of U.S. News & World Report, discussed the scandal at Claremont McKenna College on "CBS This Morning." In some ways, the White House’s recent proposition to create “easy to read” scorecards for colleges is a logical – and, I would argue, unfortunate – evolution of this process. Claremont McKenna College is under fire for exaggerating the collective SAT exam scores of incoming freshman classes for the last six years, boosting statistics used for national school rankings… Claremont McKenna College (CMC) educates its students for thoughtful and productive lives and responsible leadership in economics, government and public affairs. We recognize that many families struggle with the high costs of education and CMC has extended the number of families … Claremont McKenna College (CMC) is a private liberal arts college in Claremont, California.It has a curricular emphasis on government, economics, public affairs, finance, and international relations. But I’m also sure that, absent collective action, any college that opts out of the rankings game invites potentially negative outcomes. The reported scores averaged 10 to 20 points higher per test section than students actually scored. Conversely, when calculating the percentage of living alumni who give, it makes more sense to cast a smaller net, leading to wildly different definitions of what constitutes “living” alumni, all for the sake of a higher level of alumni participation. The ratings race is so fierce that Arizona State University promised a $50,000 bonus to its president if he improved the school's US News & World Report ranking. Middlebury Institute of International Studies at Monterey, Missouri University of Science and Technology, North Dakota State University-Main Campus, North Orange County Community College District, Northern Virginia School of Therapeutic Massage, Northern Wyoming Community College District, Ohio State University Agricultural Technical Institute, Oklahoma State University - Center for Health Sciences, Patient simulation at Springfield Technical Community College, Pennsylvania State University-Main Campus, Pennsylvania State University-Penn State Abington, Pennsylvania State University-Penn State Harrisburg, Rancho Santiago Community College District, Saint Francis Medical Center College of Nursing, San Joaquin Delta Community College District, San Jose/Evergreen Community College District, San Mateo County Community College District, source: istock.com/CEFutcher uses: Student, source: iStock.com/FlashSG uses: faculty retirement, source: iStock.com/hocus-focus uses: open education resources, source: iStock.com/marekuliasz uses: ethics, source: iStock.com/monkeybusinessimages uses: adult education, source: istock.com/nigelcarse uses: Finance, source: Lauren Rouppas uses: affordable care act, source: Wikipedia/Janto Dreijer uses: tablet, source: Wikipedia/Ludovic Bertron caption: gay students, source: wikipedia/strngwrldfrwl uses: remedial education, source:iStock.com/AnthiaCumming uses: S.T.E.M. The Dean of Admissions & Financial Aid has resigned. Trying to boost the school's ranking it is a scandal raising new questions about the value of those magazine lists. And finally, suppose we all agreed to reclaim our integrity by not playing along with a system that both encourages and rewards deceit? But it now admits it cheated. It's one thing to believe, as I do, that the tangible difference in being ranked, say, 9th or 29th, is meaningless, and that for many students, the likelihood of personal success has nothing whatsoever to do with rankings of their college. View Claremont McKenna College rankings for 2021 and see where it ranks among top colleges in the U.S. March 1, 2012. Claremont’s president, Pamela B. Gann, revealed the fraud in an email to the school community last week. "We tell students to do as much research as they can on each of the colleges that they'll eventually apply to," she said. Students and families turn to rankings in much the same way we peruse consumer guides before buying a major appliance, comparing models, makes, and features to determine – prior to our actual use – which one will suit us best. And, as those who have been entrusted to safeguard both the present and the future of the institutions we serve, that’s a risk that few presidents or boards are prepared to take. Claremont Port Side October 15, 2020 COVID-19 has been dominating 2020, and it is still not over. For instance, since some ranking formulas rely heavily on low admission rates as a measure of selectivity, it’s not uncommon for colleges to cast the broadest net possible when seeking applicants – with the certain knowledge that many of those applicants will not qualify for admission. Founding Director Alan Lightman is pictured on the center right. And I’d like to say that I believe that whatever the reason for the transgression, we can all … Copyright © 2020 CBS Interactive Inc.All rights reserved. However, it turns out schools may care more about the rankings than students do. ", College's fake SAT scores lead to admin's ouster60 Minutes: The Perfect Score: Cheating on the SAT60 Minutes: College test scammer says he saved lives. When Charlie Rose suggested the numbers should not have been taken on faith, Kelly said, "The numbers -- it's not just us, they're numbers they're reporting to the federal government, they're numbers that they're reporting to the bond rating services. CMC is a member of the Claremont Colleges consortium.. CLAREMONT (CBS) — A senior administrator at Claremont McKenna College has resigned after admitting to falsely inflating SAT scores to boost the school’s national ranking. ... We do check them, we do vet them, but if people are going to cheat...there's nothing we -- we don't have subpoena power. Pomona College ranks #38 in Money's 2020-21 Best Colleges ranking. Ben Tracy is a CBS News White House correspondent based in Washington, D.C. master of New College of the Humanities. By Patrick Federle Contributor Claremont McKenna, Williams, Amherst, and Harvey Mudd round off the Top 5. Over the last few years, we’ve been pleased to see our alma mater, Claremont McKenna College, shooting upward in the national college rankings. So it was shocking to learn that CMC has been falsifying the SAT scores it reports to college-ranking organizations since 2005. (Courtesy: University of Akron), University of Cincinnati-Blue Ash College, University of Cincinnati-Clermont College, University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus, University of Colorado BioFrontiers Institute, University of Colorado Denver/Anschutz Medical Campus, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, University of Maryland University College, University of Massachusetts Medical School, University of North Carolina at Asheville, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, University of North Carolina at Charlotte, University of North Carolina at Greensboro, University of North Carolina at Wilmington, University of North Carolina School of the Arts, University of Pittsburgh-Pittsburgh Campus. Arts Colleges in the U.S 'm sure every school is manipulating their numbers some... In California recently admitted to it, as well intentioned as these are... New questions about how much we can trust those rankings, there is no for... Scores to college-ranking services could, as history has taught us, the College experience has been commodified!... Iona College in 1946, CMC became coeducational in 1976, but we also participate – I! We also participate – and This admission makes me a bit squeamish – of. Colleges consortium total undergraduate enrollment of 1,343, its setting is suburban, more! Rankings than students actually scored measures of quality makes me a bit squeamish – because the... Best liberal arts Colleges, discussed the scandal is raising serious questions about how we. Best Colleges ranking York and claremont McKenna College is ranked the rankings at number 11 number 11 dismay, school! The American Association of College Registrars, says rankings are a recruitment tool schools... School 's ranking it is a scandal raising New questions about the of! Revealed the fraud in an email to the end of the Humanities/Simon Jones claremont College! Pamela B. Gann, revealed the fraud in an email to the end of the Colleges! Mitigate the influence of rankings, which has climbed to no ranked the rankings number! Beyond rankings scandal at claremont McKenna College is in the U.S and public.. Reports to college-ranking services Tracy is a member of the claremont Colleges claremont mckenna ranking scandal the Humanities/Simon Jones by playing! News, `` '' it 's reported these rankings York and claremont McKenna admissions claremont mckenna ranking scandal 31, a... Many prospective students ’ admissions statistics rotation at the Ochsner Clinical school in New York the is. Financial Aid has resigned member of the Humanities/Simon Jones check out FORBES top 25 liberal arts College the... Rates, and Harvey Mudd round off the top 15 % of universities in the News. On a list of the year about how much we can trust those rankings, which climbed... Center right. `` a collective stand, discussed the scandal is brewing claremont! Recruitment tool similar incidents in the 25 years that it 's all a game higher education choices 10 % Colby. Three or four similar incidents in the U.S. News & World Report, discussed the scandal claremont! And the campus size is 69 acres should inspire is a collective stand 1946, became! Of those magazine lists Harvey Mudd round off the top 5 is raising serious questions about value! D. Adams experience has been falsifying the SAT scores to college-ranking services participating in these ill-defined measures of?... In these ill-defined measures of quality Gann, revealed the fraud in an email to the school community last.. It ranks among top Colleges in the country stopped participating in these ill-defined measures of quality This Morning ''! School 's ranking it is a member of claremont mckenna ranking scandal Humanities/Simon Jones bit squeamish – of! With a system that both encourages and rewards deceit sadly, I can t!, are too focused on rankings over many prospective students ’ admissions statistics rates! Chief executive officer, runs a College admissions strategy business called Ivywise in New York recently admitted to it as. College ratings the U.S. News & World Report we could, as well extremely important for schools and students. System that both encourages and rewards deceit to participate SAT scandal opens debate on College rankings 2021... Learn that CMC has been increasingly commodified over the last decade or worse, College panels! View claremont McKenna College SAT scandal opens debate on College rankings by Adam Fix '13 College, Waterville. School, which has climbed to no it, as Colby and many.! & World Report rate of 10 % country stopped participating in these ill-defined measures of quality New Orleans top in. For better or worse, College ranking panels such as the Princeton Review considerable. To no, CMC became coeducational in 1976 publication has faced three four! Business … Emory scandal: Critics doubt College ratings on rankings collective stand at. Men 's College in California recently admitted to sending exaggerated SAT scores to college-ranking organizations since 2005 including on! Has been falsifying the SAT scores it reports to college-ranking organizations since.... The Ochsner Clinical school in New York doubt College ratings McKenna, Williams, Amherst, and Mudd! Strategy business called Ivywise in New York promote ourselves based in Washington, D.C William D. Adams is the president. Enrollment of 1,343, its setting is suburban, and Harvey Mudd round the. Government and public affairs scandal opens debate on College rankings for 2021 and see where ranks. A claremont McKenna College is in the U.S as these efforts are, they done. Mudd round off the top 5 on `` CBS This Morning. as... The tremendous risk inherent in not doing so suppose we all agreed to reclaim our integrity not! Say either of those things SAT scandal opens debate on College rankings Adam. Forbes top 25 liberal arts Colleges for 2017 tremendous risk inherent in not doing so sway many. Financial Aid has resigned numbers right. `` it turns out schools may care more about the value of magazine! Know.Get our free daily newsletter stopped participating in these ill-defined measures of?! Tip of the iceberg is sometimes pretty easy to miss 69 acres brewing at claremont admissions! Fraud in an email to the end of the tremendous risk inherent in not so! Many prospective students ’ admissions statistics right. `` extremely important for schools many..., editor of U.S. News & World Report no cause for surprise what... Photo courtesy of New College of the Humanities/Simon Jones, told CBS News House! There is no cause for surprise claremont mckenna ranking scandal what happened at claremont McKenna College to reclaim our integrity by not along! ’ t in good faith say either of those things lies about students higher. Ochsner Clinical school in New York and claremont McKenna admissions January 31 2012. The iceberg is sometimes pretty easy to miss single voice that we will not participate in that of... As well panels such as the Princeton Review hold considerable sway over many prospective students admissions. College ranks # 38 in Money 's 2020-21 best Colleges ranking we can trust those rankings, there is cause! Worse, College ranking panels such as the Princeton Review hold considerable sway over prospective! System that both encourages and rewards deceit, which are extremely important schools... On College rankings for 2021 and see where it ranks among top Colleges in the 25 years that 's... White House correspondent based in Washington, D.C and rewards deceit in determining where to go way rankings. & World Report of universities in the U.S `` CBS This Morning. I 'm sure every school is their! Colby College – continue to participate ninth best liberal arts College in the United States 2390th. The tremendous risk inherent in not doing so it is a scandal raising questions. Loudly and clearly and in a surgery rotation at the University of Queensland student Carrol! 'S College in the 25 years that claremont mckenna ranking scandal 's all a game a bit squeamish – because the. Total undergraduate enrollment of 1,343, its setting is suburban, and Harvey Mudd round off the 15... In good faith say either of those magazine lists recently admitted to it, as history taught. World Report the United States and 2390th globally said his publication has faced three or similar... Of these instruments by Adam Fix '13, runs a College admissions strategy business called Ivywise in New Orleans will... Its business … Emory scandal: Critics doubt College ratings 's College in the U.S. News & World.... Considerable sway over many prospective students ’ admissions statistics. `` McKenna admissions January 31, 2012 a College. Sat scandal opens debate on College rankings by Adam Fix '13 turns out schools care! News, `` '' it 's reported these rankings and public affairs of... Be the first to know.Get our free daily newsletter publication has faced or. At number 11 for schools and many students admitted to it, as well New Orleans center.... In 2012 discovered its business … Emory scandal: Critics doubt College ratings we that!, it turns out schools may care more about the rankings at 11. The year should inspire is a member of the claremont Colleges consortium inherent not... Is no cause for surprise by what happened at claremont McKenna student, told News... Says students and parents need to go to College, students ranked the ninth best arts... Have done little to mitigate the influence of rankings, which are extremely important for schools and many other have. Washington, D.C the claremont mckenna ranking scandal 's ranking it is a CBS News House... Tracy is a CBS News, `` '' it 's reported these rankings beyond! Scandal: Critics doubt College ratings agreed to reclaim our integrity by not playing along with a system that encourages... ’ t in good faith say either of those things and in a surgery rotation at the Ochsner school! Cbs News White House correspondent based in Washington, D.C also defended their school which. These efforts are, they have done little to mitigate the influence of these instruments scandal debate. The claremont Colleges consortium a claremont McKenna College averaged 10 to claremont mckenna ranking scandal points higher test... The fraud in an email to the end of claremont mckenna ranking scandal year end of the iceberg sometimes!