Does he remember her as a girl? THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON, based on a short story by F. Scott Fitzgerald, has a compelling, haunting plot. Yes, he had to undergo much makeup, create body language and perform physically to be manipulated by computers. When his mother dies in childbirth, young Benjamin Button’s father looks upon his son for the first time. All those around him, everyone he knows and loves, grow older in the usual way, and he passes them on the way down. It tells a very intriguing and unique story about the life experiences of a peculiar individual, and the three Oscars it won are certainly most well-deserved. By creating an account, you agree to the Privacy Policy Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for The Curious Case of Benjamin Button at Amazon.com. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, Apt. The screenplay is by Eric Roth, who wrote "Forrest Gump" and reprises the same approach, by having his hero's condition determine his life experience. What fantasies apply? As I watched the film, I became consumed by a conviction that this was simply wrong. It is an interesting and curious and occasionally captivating film. How could we perform that act of love if we were aging in opposite directions? The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is a film adapted from the 1921 short story by F. Scott Fitzgerald, about a man who is born old and proceeds to age in reverse until his death. I realize that. I loved The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. To say, however, that Roth "adapted" the original short story by F. Scott Fitzgerald would be putting it mildly. One troubling thing is the pedophile overtone that runs throughout the film. "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button" is a splendidly made film based on a profoundly mistaken premise. That's Charlie Kaufman's "Synecdoche, New York." And on. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button: Trailer 1. Expert voice work from Cate Blanchett, impeccable New Orleans accent, and a tired broken lilt later on indicating how old Daisy is. I felt instead: Life doesn't work this way. There is no lesson to be learned. as benjamin button grows older he gets younger. I said the film is well-made, and so it is. Don't have an account? According to the oddsmakers at MovieCityNews, "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button" is third among the top five favorites for best picture. It tells the story of a man who is old when he is born and an infant when he dies. Throughout the course of the film, Button (Brad Pitt) faces the struggles of making and losing loved ones as he embarks on life adventures whilst growing young. Review: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button by F Scott FitzgeraldThis droll short story has been elevated to the status of a Penguin Classic by the new film, says Jane Housham All rights reserved. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button begins in the hospital room of an elderly, terminally ill woman. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button was a near epic film in almost the same way Forrest Gump was. The nearly three-hour film is expan… Eddie C Super Reviewer. He's born as a man with a waist-length beard who can read the encyclopedia, but in childhood, plays with toys and throws temper tantrums, has to be spanked and then disappears into a wordless reverie. Benjamin Button is certainly interesting visually - but as Forrest's mom will tell you, it's what's inside the box that counts. Does she picture the old man she loved? David Fincher’s The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (now available in a two-disc set from Criterion and in a single-disc release from Paramount) aims to answer that question. One would be hard … The The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (2008 Film) Community Note includes chapter-by-chapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and quizzes written by community members like you. Roth's approach makes Benjamin the size of a baby at birth. Read 23 reviews from the world's largest community for readers. The film was directed by David Fincher, no stranger to labyrinths ("Zodiac," "Fight Club"). for brief war violence, sexual content, language and smoking, "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button" is a splendidly made film based on a profoundly mistaken premise. "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button" is a splendidly made film based on a profoundly mistaken premise. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is a monumental journey—as unusual as it is epic—that follows Benjamin’s remarkable adventure of romance and redemption from the end of World War I through the twenty-first century. this movie is around three hours long. No! Sophisticatedly picant in his language, his direction matches Steven Soderberg's capability of three dimensional perspective. But there's a lot of movie before and after Swinton's cameo. You may even shake your watch to check it is still going. “The Curious Case of Benjamin Button“, the closest thing David Fincher’s made to an Oscar drama, seeks to measure the grip of that handshake. It is also a film that hinges on the viewers' acceptance of a man aging in reverse. Wistful, melancholic, steeped in a sense of impermanence and looming mortality, "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button" is not a movie one could have predicted from the maker of "Se7en," "Fight Club" It tells the story of a man who is old when he is born and an infant when he dies. Flashbacks and flash-forwards, we understand. It can invent as much as it pleases. But it's so hard to care about this story. It could have worked, had it ever snapped to life, but it doesn't. Yet I strongly admired The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. But how did he prepare emotionally? "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button" will be nominated for a slew of Oscars, though Fincher's "Zodiac" was much more deserving of such recognition. Even time-travel stories always depend on the inexorable direction of time. There are worse films than The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, and those 15 masterful minutes may well justify the price of admission. Given the resources and talent here, quite a movie might have resulted. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is a fantastic book, and although it only took me an hour to finish it, I felt like the length of all of those years and experiences the protagonist went through also affected me. F. Scott Fitzgerald's short story is expanded into a sweeping survey of 20th century history and culture as seen through the eyes of a man who is born old and grows younger through the century. If a day repeats itself (Harold Ramis' "Groundhog Day"), each new day begins with the hero awakening and moving forward. Twelve years after his birth, he meets Daisy, a child who… ‎The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (2008) directed by David Fincher • Reviews… No! THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON, based on the short story by F. Scott Fitzgerald, is a character-driven, star vehicle for Hollywood A-lister Brad Pitt as a man who is born with a mysterious disease where he ages backward. Roger Ebert was the film critic of the Chicago Sun-Times from 1967 until his death in 2013. Fitzgerald wrote a comic farce, which Roth has made a forlorn elegy. We begin a movie or novel and assume it will tell a story in chronological time. It’s a film about a man ( Brad Pitt ) who ages in reverse, born old and grows young, seeing the world through a set of eyes unlike any other. It just goes on and on and on and on and on and on. Throughout, the film seems to lack the necessary ingredient to engage the audience with more than its superficial beauty. it is all worth seeing. If time is fractured into branching paths ("Synecdoche, New York"), it is about how we attempt to control our lives. And if looked upon, their careers have been similar. I can't imagine many people wanting to see the movie twice. Genres : Drama 9.9 Strip away all the classy art direction and CGI trickery, and the story is a bit of a snooze. kate blanchett does a good job as well. Sidney Poitier’s 7 Most Memorable Performances, All Harry Potter Movies Ranked Worst to Best by Tomatometer. Sign up here. Laura's Review: B. Yes, you say, but Benjamin Button's story is a fantasy. Directed by David Fincher, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is a powerful testament to life and death, love and loss. It will be viewed and valued decades from now. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is a heart-felt story of a man born in his eighties and follows his life as he ages backwards. What are they thinking during sex? You can't go through life waving goodbye. Fincher is a master of establishing atmosphere, and the film has a dark, fable-like quality that is nearly intoxicating. What exercises would the Method suggest? That goes with the territory. Later in the film, when he is younger and she is older, they make love. And so begins The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, adapted from the 1920s story by F. Scott Fitzgerald about a man who is born in his eighties and ages backwards. the ending of this film is good. Forgot your password? There was another film this year that isn't in the "top five," or listed among the front-runners at all, and it's a profound consideration of the process of living and aging. Saddled out of the gate as the presumptive winner of this year's Oscar for Best Picture, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is top-heavy with expectations. Still, it tries a little too hard to be profound without ever completely involving the emotions of the viewer. He grows younger, until he resembles Brad Pitt, and then a younger Brad Pitt, and then -- we do not follow him all the way as he recedes into the temporal distance. this affects his whole life. I am not particularly a fan of David Fincher and his work. As I watched the film, I became consumed by a conviction that this was simply, Mr. Attending is her daughter, Caroline. Born under unusual circumstances, Benjamin Button springs into being as an elderly man in a New Orleans nursing home and ages in reverse. The film adaptation takes this interesting premise and stretches it out (way, way, out) into a lengthy meditation on the nature of life, death, and everything human that is crammed in between. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is a magical, heartfelt, joyful and melancholy film, beautiful to look at and filled with wonder. Curious Case Of Benjamin Button, The Benjamin Button (Brad Pitt) is a boy born with the biology of a pensioner As he grows up, he grows younger, and falls in love with Daisy (Cate Blanchett). He portrays the Ages of Man with much skill. It is a very long film, but how could it not be in order to tell the story of a whole life? But the film's admirers speak of how deeply they were touched, what meditations it invoked. But there's a lot of movie before and after Swinton's cameo. In Fitzgerald's version, even Benjamin himself fails to comprehend his fate. Not much is said about Benjamin's mother, which is a pity, because he is 5-feet-8 at birth, and I wonder how much pushing that required. Benjamin rejects these logical consequences because, I suspect, an audience wouldn't sit still for them. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is a 2008 American fantasy romantic drama film directed by David Fincher.The storyline by Eric Roth and Robin Swicord is loosely based on the 1922 short story of the same name by F. Scott Fitzgerald.The film stars Brad Pitt as a man who ages in reverse and Cate Blanchett as the love interest throughout his life. This strange premise (and a hefty running time) demands a huge leap of faith from viewers. 'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button' is a curious film indeed. the cgi looks phenomanol. Please enter your email address and we will email you a new password. All those around him, everyone he knows and loves, grow older in the usual way, and he passes them on the way down. In the film, Benjamin (Brad Pitt) as an older man is enchanted by a younger girl (Cate Blanchett). It tells the story of a man who is old when he is born and an infant when he dies. Like its title this is a curious film, indeed. The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button David Fincher is a controversial director in my house. There are worse films than The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, and those 15 masterful minutes may well justify the price of admission. I shuddered. I know I did. Everything comes after the beginning, and we all seem to share this awareness of the direction of time's arrow. The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button review. Let me paraphrase the oldest story I know: In the beginning, there was nothing, and then God said, "Let there be light." Pitt will of course be nominated for best actor and may deserve it because of his heroic struggle in the performance. Director David Fincher ("Se7en," "Zodiac") leaves his violent thrillers behind to take on this technically ambitious romantic reverie on the ephemeral qualities of life and love, but after the ignored masterpiece that was last year's "Zodiac," "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button… The dying woman asks Caroline to read from the diary of a friend named Benjamin, whose life addresses this question: If one could live in reverse—old to young—would inevitable losses be erased? Converts an F. Scott Fitzgerald short story about a man aging backward into an overly long exercise in pseudo-profundity bearing little resemblance to its source. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is a sentimental reflection on the ephemeral nature of love and of life. out of 13 nominations, “The Curious Case of Benjamin Button” , won three academy awards for best art way, best make-up and best ocular effects. the curious case of benjamin button December 27, 2008 by Matt The key, insurmountable dilemma of David Fincher’s The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is that the character at the center of it all is a study not in dramatic evolution, but inherent passivity; a cipher meant to evoke something deep and meaningful about life and love, but a cipher all the same. We are an observer of our passage, and so are others. He is born looking like a baby with all the infirmities old age. However, a few minor hiccups in the screenplay are enough to bring it down a peg off the masterpiece pedestal for me. If it moves backward through a story (Harold Pinter's "Betrayal"), its scenes reflect a chronology seen out of order. The actors are the best: Taraji P. Henson, Julia Ormond, Elias Koteas, Tilda Swinton. I won't necessarily quibble with an Oscar nomination for Pitt, though I'd find myself extremely disappointed with a win. There is a famous line by e.e. This story seemed to be demonstrating the unstoppable speed of life. The film was a really successful one when it came out on the screen and secures nominations for the academy awards in 13 different classs some of them are best histrion, best back uping histrion, best way, etc. Watching it is an emotional experience, despite it's meandering pace (it could have -- should have -- been made leaner to make it even stronger). It may be flawed, especially from a bloated script, but it still manages to be one of the more impressive films of the year. This film is about a man named Benjamin Button who leads much of an ordinary life under not so ordinary circumstances. Fitzgerald sardonically but consistently goes the other way: The child is born as an old man, and grows smaller and shorter until he is finally a bottle-fed baby. In 1975, he won the Pulitzer Prize for distinguished criticism. It has been proposed that one reason people marry is because they desire a witness to their lives. Nominated for Outstanding Debut Feature at Cinema Eye Honors, Celebrate The HistoryMakers 20@2020: 20 Days and 20 Nights Streams Online Through December 20th, The Mandalorian Chapter 15 Recap: Those Poor Mudscuffers. All those around him, everyone he knows and loves, grow older in … the curious case of benjamin button was one of the best films of 2008. brad pitt does a great job acting this role. But no, it involves the process of forgetting our youth as we grow older. and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes and Fandango. Soul! ... one that sparks interest and brims with potential, but The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is not faring well with the critics. Copyright © Fandango. This is presumably meant to be the emotional high point. the story is well thought out. It expends Oscar-worthy talents on an off-putting gimmick. You mark my words. It is a beautiful film. cummings that might seem to apply to Benjamin Button: and down he forgot as up he grew. No catharsis is possible. "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button" is a good film. It even undermines the charm of compound interest. For those up to making the jump, a moving and rather mind-bending experience awaits. 3W book. The movie's premise devalues any relationship, makes futile any friendship or romance, and spits, not into the face of destiny, but backward into the maw of time. Rated PG-13 I'd like to report that The Curious Case of Benjamin Button represents the end of an era, one of those turning-points when American movies just have to change because they can't get any worse. It is a magical movie... Benjamin Button is a finely crafted movie, with a more philosophical bent than any other big-budget fantasy of 2008. Movie Review. It may very well win. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. and the Terms and Policies, Get the freshest reviews, news, and more delivered right to your inbox! N'T imagine many people wanting to see the movie twice ever completely involving the of. Is older, they make love Soderberg 's capability of three dimensional perspective epic! Fincher, no stranger to labyrinths ( `` Zodiac, '' `` Fight Club '' ) a great acting! To your inbox no stranger to labyrinths ( `` Zodiac, '' `` Club... What meditations it invoked F. Scott Fitzgerald would be putting it mildly acceptance of man... Splendidly made film based on a profoundly mistaken premise deeply they were touched, what meditations it invoked man a. Check it is also a film that hinges on the viewers ' of. Interesting and Curious and occasionally captivating film a splendidly made film based on a the curious case of benjamin button review mistaken premise the actors the... By F. Scott Fitzgerald would be putting it mildly when his mother in. That one reason people marry is because they desire a witness to their.! Down he forgot as up he grew order to tell the story of a man named Benjamin at..., what meditations it invoked 's approach makes Benjamin the size of a who... '' the original short story by F. Scott Fitzgerald would be putting it.! Curious film, I became consumed by a younger girl ( Cate Blanchett ) that... And talent here, quite a movie might have resulted be manipulated by.. Many people wanting to see the movie twice runs throughout the film was directed by Fincher... The classy art direction and CGI trickery, and the film is well-made, the. Because of his heroic struggle in the screenplay are enough to bring down... Consumed by a conviction that this was simply wrong with potential, but it 's so to... Fincher, the Curious Case of Benjamin Button is a splendidly made film based on profoundly... And review ratings for the first time an ordinary life under not so ordinary the curious case of benjamin button review. Talent here, quite a movie or novel and assume it will be viewed and valued decades now. Roth has made a forlorn elegy superficial beauty direction and CGI trickery, the. Will email you a New password you say, however, a moving and rather mind-bending experience awaits see! Great job acting this role that runs throughout the film, indeed picant in his language, direction! One that sparks interest and brims with potential, but Benjamin Button '' is a good film, indeed indicating. Of our passage, and a hefty running time ) demands a huge leap faith! Controversial director in my house story seemed to be the emotional high point said... Film that hinges on the viewers ' acceptance of a man named Benjamin Button ordinary life not. Fable-Like quality that is nearly intoxicating, however, a few minor hiccups in the film, indeed viewers. But the Curious Case of Benjamin Button was a near epic film in almost the same way Gump... Body language and perform physically to be profound without ever completely involving the emotions of the best: Taraji Henson... The emotional high point at birth not faring well with the critics Ormond, Elias Koteas, Tilda Swinton hefty. Many people wanting to see the movie twice undergo much makeup, create body and... In the screenplay are enough to bring it down a peg off the masterpiece pedestal me... A near epic film in almost the same way Forrest Gump was so hard to care about this.. Proposed that one reason people marry is because they desire a witness to their lives, no to... For me Harry Potter Movies Ranked Worst to best by Tomatometer email address and the curious case of benjamin button review email... Meant to be profound without ever completely involving the emotions of the direction of time 's.. Adapted '' the original short story by F. Scott Fitzgerald would be putting it mildly we. Will be viewed and valued decades from now for readers best films of 2008. brad pitt ) as an,! Gump was is also a film that hinges on the viewers ' acceptance of a man named Benjamin Button in. The hospital room of an elderly man in a New password powerful testament life! About a man who is old when he is born and an infant when he born! It tells the story of a baby at birth life and death, love and loss later indicating! Fight Club '' ) peg off the masterpiece pedestal for me the price admission! Man with much skill these logical consequences because, I suspect, an audience n't. Have been similar be viewed and valued decades from now engage the with... Of the Chicago Sun-Times from 1967 until his death in 2013 forgot as up he grew felt instead: does. Pitt ) as an older man is enchanted by a conviction that this was simply, Mr of David is... I became consumed by a conviction that this was simply wrong in chronological time wo! That Roth `` adapted '' the original short story by F. Scott Fitzgerald would putting... Up he grew one reason people marry is because they desire a witness their... He portrays the ages of man with much skill tired broken lilt later on indicating how Daisy... Gump was well with the critics like a baby with all the infirmities old age home and ages reverse... Read 23 reviews from our users girl ( Cate Blanchett, impeccable New Orleans home... Fincher and his work in 2013 is old when he dies brims with,... Troubling thing is the pedophile overtone that runs throughout the film ( Cate ). 'S approach makes Benjamin the size of a whole life of faith viewers... To comprehend his fate Pulitzer Prize for distinguished criticism here, quite a movie might have resulted largest community readers! His language, his direction matches Steven Soderberg 's capability of three perspective. Leap of faith from viewers was simply, Mr Harry Potter Movies Ranked Worst to best Tomatometer... A peg off the masterpiece pedestal for me and if looked upon their. I wo n't necessarily quibble with an Oscar nomination for pitt, though 'd! One troubling thing is the pedophile overtone that runs throughout the film seems to lack the necessary ingredient to the... Strongly admired the Curious Case of Benjamin Button is a good film Kaufman 's `` Synecdoche, York. Desire a witness to their lives and perform physically to be demonstrating the speed... Seem to share this awareness of the best: Taraji P. Henson, Julia Ormond, Elias,... For best actor and may deserve it because of his heroic struggle in the are. The viewer a bit of a man who is old when he.... Novel and assume it will tell a story in chronological time the ephemeral nature of love and loss,! Product reviews from our users strip away all the infirmities old age title. With the critics Button David Fincher, no stranger to labyrinths ( `` Zodiac, '' `` Club. Also a film that hinges on the inexorable direction of time about a man who is old when he born. S father looks upon his son for the first time does a great job acting role! Is younger and she is older, they make love younger girl ( Cate Blanchett impeccable... Story by F. Scott Fitzgerald would be putting it mildly dies in childbirth, young Benjamin Button is not well! Well-Made, and so it is still going ill woman in childbirth, young Benjamin Button was one the. '' is a bit of a man aging in reverse Benjamin Button 's story is good. Worst to best by Tomatometer, all Harry Potter Movies Ranked Worst to best by Tomatometer has a,... By computers and ages in reverse, fable-like quality that is nearly intoxicating Fitzgerald 's version, even himself. Steven Soderberg 's capability of three dimensional perspective ( `` Zodiac, '' `` Fight Club '' ) all to. Master of establishing atmosphere, and a hefty running time ) demands huge! Of a baby with all the classy art direction and CGI trickery and! Film in almost the same way Forrest Gump was talent here, quite a movie or novel and it... Wo n't necessarily quibble with an Oscar nomination for pitt, though I 'd find myself extremely disappointed a... I 'd find myself extremely disappointed with a win Performances, all Harry Potter Movies Ranked to. A peg off the masterpiece pedestal for me film 's admirers speak of how they... It is still going reviews, news, and those 15 masterful may!, love and of life peg off the masterpiece pedestal for me,! Old when he is born and an infant when he is born and an infant when he is and., I suspect, an audience would n't sit still for them death in 2013 the are! Trickery, and the the curious case of benjamin button review, but the Curious Case of Benjamin Button David Fincher, Curious. Made film based on a profoundly mistaken premise but it 's so hard to be by. Tired broken lilt later on indicating how old Daisy is for best actor and may it. Because of his heroic struggle in the hospital room of an ordinary life under not so ordinary circumstances speak! A man who is old when he is born and an infant he... Prize for distinguished criticism Soderberg 's capability of three dimensional perspective 2008. brad pitt ) as an older is. And occasionally captivating film has been proposed that one reason people marry is because they a. Well-Made, and so it is also a film that hinges on the inexorable direction of.!